(GM) General Musings: Marlon Byrd

The Cincinnati Reds have acquired veteran outfielder Marlon Byrd in a trade with the Philadelphia Phillies, a baseball source confirmed to ESPN.com.


KT: Not sure if I would give up Ben Lively for this guy.

ML: This is an interesting one. I think the Phillies come out ahead in this deal. Byrd is 37, and although he hit 25 HRs last year, Lively has some significant upside. You think this is a precursor to Cole Hamels getting traded? He obviously isn’t a direct replacement for Hamels, but could fill in a 3rd or 4th starter role very soon. How much does Byrd’s $8M contract + option year play into this? (It’s a club option, not a player option).

KT: The Phillies have done well so far this offseason. Ben Lively for a 37 year old Marlon Byrd, Tom Windle and Zach Eflin for an over the hill Jimmy Rollins (35). If you are the Phillies, you have to trade anything of value at this point. I expect Hamels to be dealt soon. Philly can’t afford to wait until the deadline should something happen to Hamels. No one expected Roy Halladay to become irrelevant so quickly and they can’t make the same mistake here (not saying they should have traded Halladay). I would even eat a lot of the salary of Cliff Lee if I could get some decent prospects in return.

KT: From the Reds side of things, I can understand the deal but I still don’t like it. Cincy’s best prospects are pitchers and I can see why they saw Lively as expendable. I just don’t like trading prospects for a 37 year old, who’s production could drop off a cliff at any moment.

KT: Especially when you can get similar “pop” from a guy like Mike Morse who is younger, costs the same, and wouldn’t have cost any prospects in return.

ML: I still don’t get the deal. Is Marlon still the stolen base threat he once was? His defense has to be much better than Morse has to offer right?

KT: No question. Morse has to be top 3 worst defensive players in the game. The Reds GM stated that this move was to add “pop” in the middle of the lineup. In terms of pop, I fear Morse more than Byrd. Either way this is a sideways move that doesn’t make sense for Cincy.

KT: It’s only a matter of time before Byrd gets busted for PEDs again.

Categories: (GM) General Musings

Tags: , ,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: