Player Comparison: Pablo Sandoval & Casey McGehee

The San Francisco Giants have traded for Casey McGehee, who, most likely, is only a one-year solution to replace the swinging Panda, Pablo Sandoval. While on the surface it seems like a big downgrade, I believe the Giants will find hidden benefits from this signing. Let’s take a deeper look at the two players. (In each comparison, Pablo is on the left and Casey is on the right).

pablo and casey

Comparative Career Statistics (as of 2013 season)
pablo and casey1

Pablo added 16 homeruns in 2014, while having a slash line of .278/.324/.415.  Casey hit only 4 homeruns in 2014 (after spending the 2013 season in Japan) and have a slash line of .287/.355/.357. It is quite clear that the Giants will miss the Panda’s bat.  Pablo is a superior hitter across the board when looking at OOTP15’s batting ratings.

Comparative Batting Ratings
pablo and casey batting

But the Giants didn’t sign Casey to replace Pablo from an offensive perspective. Casey’s real value will come on defense. Though he has a slightly weaker arm and may make a few more errors, Casey’s ability to turn double plays is much better than Pablo. But Casey can fill in elsewhere too. He can be a serviceable corner outfielder, and an above average first baseman if/when Brandon Belt needs a break.

Comparative Fielding Ratings
pablo and casey fielding

Without a doubt, the Giants will miss Pablo’s offense, and still need to find a replacement bat. But signing McGehee is definately a great move by Giants GM Brian Sabean.

Categories: MLB

Tags: ,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: